Wednesday, March 18, 2009

Weighing the Pros and Cons of lowering the drinking age

  • The entire debate started in the 1970's and it getting much more heated as time goes on.
  • All states are able to make whatever drinking age they want to.
  • It's kind of as though Congress bribed each state to raise the age in 1984 because they would lose 10% of all highway funds if it was a lower age.
  • A lot of states have been trying to lower the drinking age recently .
  • Some for military personnel only, other for 19 and 20-year-olds to buy low-alcohol beer and some for 18-year-olds and older to buy alcohol in bars and restaurants, but not in liquor stores.
  • It's all a little weird when you think about it.

Arguments in favor of a lower age:

  • The United States has the highest drinking age in the world. Normal ages are 16 or 18 and in some cases like China, there is no age.
  • People are arguing if you can vote, get married, adopt and purchase firearms, they you can be trusted to drink alcohol.
  • Because of the age, teens are forced to sneak alcohol and no one really has an affect on how teens are doing this.
  • Some think that because the age is 21 it's not lowering the age of drinkers at all.
  • A change would educate teens and teach them to drink responsibly.

Arguments against a lower age:

  • During the Vietnam war, 29 states lowered the drinking age because if people could die for their country, they could drink alcohol.
  • But, soon the lower age resulted in a lot of alcohol-related traffic fatalities.
  • Lowering the age resulted in more fatalities by 10%.
  • Alcohol is the leading cause of death among teens.
  • The states would have to lose 10% of their highway funds and not many want that.
  • It's said it looks like a lower age is not likely.

Response to Teen drinking and mixed messages

I think it's highly suprising that Maine has the highest rate of underage drinking. When I think of drinking I think of New York and California the more larger areas and the more populated. I don't really ever think of Maine. I guess it's because it's easier to get away with it and that's what teens are looking for nowadays. I can definitely understand the conflict around the drinking age no problem. It's not just in one place it's everywhere, and everyone is dealing with it too. I think it's a major problem that some people don't think it's a big deal that teens are drinking as much as they are because of the health risks. Even if you are for drinking, it's obviously a big problem and you should still be aware of the health risks. That's just unacceptable.

Teen Drinking and Mixed Messages

  • Maine is becoming known to have the highest rate of underage drinking in North America.
  • Also the highest substance abuse.
  • One of the major reasons teens are drinking so much is because it's "cool".
  • There is currently a conflict between the way our society views the drinking age.
  • There have been mixed messages between how teens are being pressured to drink.
  • Even though there are major health risks with drinking, some think that it's not that big of a deal that teens are drinking as much as they are.

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Response to Interview

I think that it was good that I got the point of view from someone you was involved in the underage drinking. I've been used to just finding information on websites and I don't know who this information is coming from. It was really helpful to see this person's point of view and know that it's the truth. It's shocking to see that this person started drinking when they were 11 just to cope with what was going on in their life. I personally think it would have been easier to talk to someone but that's just not the way they wanted to deal with the situation. I'm obviously keeping the drinker anonymous because they are underage, but I interviewed them two days ago over e-mail. I'm not really sure how to react to the interview. All I know is that I got a lot of information that I needed. After learning how alcohol makes someone feel and what it does to them, I'm beginning to see a trend. That people drink not because they like it, but because of the way it makes them feel. Some are responsible with it and others not so much. It's going to be fun interviewing someone who is totally against underage drinking to get their point of view on the matter and compare the two ideas. After completing the next interview, I think I'll be able to take a side and form a very good argument.

Interview with drinker

What they think about drinking..

How old are you?

Almost 16.

How long have you been drinking and why do you do it?

I started drinking when I was 11. I drank quite a bit because I had a lot going on and I felt like it made it better. It did make me feel better to a point. It made me forget about things for a while, I used it as something like a getaway. I got drunk almost every week from when I was 11 to when I was probably 12 and a half. I don’t drink as often as I did now, it took a long time to stop drinking the way that I did but I’ve done it. I still drink at parties and stuff because I feel like it’s a lot of fun. It makes me not care as much about things, more laid back.

Do you enjoy how it makes you feel?

I love how it makes me feel. It makes me chill out, I don’t care about much. But I have had plenty of black out nights and I hate those nights. I puke a lot and the whole night sucks. I’ve learned to control how much a drink a lot better though.

Have you ever driven or driven with someone who has been drunk?

I’ve never driven when I’m drunk but I have been with people who’ve been drunk.

What do think the risks of drinking are and does it really matter to you? Why or why not?

I think the risks of drinking are plenty but I feel like it’s my life and if this is what I want to do then I’ll do it. So even though I think about the risks sometimes they don’t really matter to me because I haven’t seen the effect of drinking on myself at all. I feel like I’m the same person that I’ve always been.

Do you think the drinking age should be lowered or kept the same? Why?

I feel like it doesn’t even matter if the drinking age is lowered, it would just be less people getting into trouble. It’s obvious that if the drinking age is 21, people who are under the age of 21 are still going to drink it’s just illegal. It will be that same thing if the drinking age is 18, but the 18, 19, and 20 year olds who drink won’t get into trouble.

Do think it would really make a difference what the age was?

Not at all, people will still do what they want.

Do you think teens would be more responsible if the age was lowered?

I don’t think that it would make a difference, so no. They'd still act the same as they do now.

Would there be less drinking, in your opinion, if the age was lowered?

I don’t think there would be less drinking at all, if anything there would be more drinking.

When do you think the controversy between the two sides will cease?

I don’t think it ever will because there are lots of people that have strong opinions on both sides. People aren’t going to just stop believing in what they’re saying.

Are you going to continue drinking for the rest of your life?

Yes, probably unless I have some traumatic experience that changes my mind.

Do you care what others think about your drinking?

I really don’t. There are things about everyone that you don’t like, mine just may be that I drink. I think that you should be your own person and do what you feel is right/okay. Even though this is illegal, I feel like I can control my drinking better than lots of adults.




Thursday, March 5, 2009

Final Focus; further research needed.

After doing as much research as I have, I've been able to focus my thoughts on one idea, the drinking age. Even though I chose to focus on the drinking age, I also am trying to focus on some of the statistics and I think that is what I am going to base my interactive activity on during my oral presentation. There's a lot on major controversy on the whole idea of the drinking age. Should it be lowered or should it stay the same? I haven't been able to come up with my own opinion on the matter yet. I haven't done enough research to form a firm argument yet. The next step in my process is interviewing two people. First, to interview someone who is totally against underage drinking and see what their thoughts and opinions are on the whole idea of the drinking age. Then, I'm thinking about interviewing someone who is underage and is drinking. I'm going to have to keep this person anonymous, of course, but I think I will be able to get the information still. I think after doing this I will be able to form a better argument and possibly take a side on the controversy. If not, then I'm going to continue my research and try and form stronger points on each side. I also discovered that I needed to know more about why the drinking age is such an issue and I haven't actually found that information yet. When I do find this out, it's going to be a huge step in my research because as of right now, I'm not really sure why it's such a controversy.
Brainstorming for Oral Presentation:
  • Do and "Who Wants to Be a Millionaire" type of interactive game on the statistics of drunk driving and just on statistics of drinking. I think it may be interesting to see how knowledgeable the class is. Just spilt them up into groups and quiz them on it. Kind of go in a circle and keep track of points and such. I don't want to take up too much time or make the activity too difficult.
  • I need to try and make categories or something like it and just find a lot of facts for each one. If I do this then I should make a substantive lecture because it will show how knowledgeable I am. But, not just by listing off facts after facts but also putting my input and the input of others in there.
  • I will do a sort of pros and cons type of thing for the drinking age and possibly take a poll to see which side the class will take after fully sharing my research with them. This would be just to see if my information was sufficient and specific enough to take a side and fully understand what they're debating about.
  • I need to make a poster board or something like that for a visual presentation. I would put the facts on it that I would read and the whole idea about the controversy around the drinking age. Also probably just any facts that I found interesting about underage drinking. Possibly a story that a person that drank when they were underage shared and how they are now. Such as, if they're an alcoholic or what.

Thursday, January 29, 2009

Response to The Toll of underage drinking

This was a really helpful article because I was having trouble finding information overall on my topic. I didn't really know what aspect of the topic to research and I got a good idea from a classmate and went on it. It was good to see the different parts of the idea. I think it's sad that so many people die each year from drinking. It shouldn't be like that. People should be more responsible of themselves and stop drinking so much. Innocent people are dying because people want to drink alcohol. It doesn't make a lot of sense and their lives are being thrown away. Not only does alcohol impair your judgement to make good choices, but it also affects your body mentally and physically to a higher degree. The whole teen mother thing is upsetting too. I don't think that I would ever make that mistake. I'm not sure how much alcohol you would have to drink to get that way but I'm pretty sure that's a problem.

The Toll of Underage Drinking

Here are some effects of drinking--

Drunk Driving:
  • Around 3 teens are killed each day from drinking and driving and around 6 are killed a day from other alcohol related accidents.
  • Alcohol is involved in 38% of automobile crashes every year.
  • A survey of college students showed that 26% of students have driven after they have had alcohol, 10% after they've had five or more drinks, and almost 25% with someone completely drunk or high.

Alcohol Dependence

  • It's shown that teenage girls who binge drink are up to 63% more likely to become a mother as a teenager.
  • If you start drinking before the age of 13, when you get to college you will drink more and do things you will regret. Things that aren't planned.

Health Consequences

  • 4,554 deaths a year are from excessive alcohol.
  • Alcohol is a major part of the top three leading causes of death in teens; unintentional injuries, suicides, and homicides.
  • Those who begin drinking before the age of 14 are more likely to be injured after the age of 21 by alcohol related injuries.
  • Drinking a lot before the age of 21 impairs brain development.

Social Consequences

  • The cost of underage drinking is approximately 53 Billion dollars a year because of medical costs.
  • A study of 6,500 people showed that by the age of 23 they were more likely to be criminals compared to those who don't drink.

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Brittney's Third Response

Kari, I think you are really doing a great job so far. You did everything correctly, and I found nothing wrong with the three of the articles. Just keep working hard, and I'm sure your blog will turn out great!

Saturday, January 10, 2009

Luca's third response

Hey, You are doing a great job and finding valuable information. I thought it was great that you found and article tha compared the United States to other countries. Your blog is great. Good luck with finding more great articles and information. Keep up the good work.

Friday, January 9, 2009

Alex's Third Response

I don't think there is anything wrong with your last three articles. I found the information you found on the underage drinking article interesting. Keep up the good work.

Olivia's 3rd Response

Kari,
There is a lot of information here! Some of it I had no idea about... I always thought of the U.S. as the devil when it came to drinking, but there's actual facts out there that say that we're not the worst. You don't ever hear that! It's always the United States. It's nice to know that there're facts saying that we're not number one anymore :) Anyway, your blog is pretty much perfect! Keep up the good work girlie <33

Liv

Wednesday, January 7, 2009

Laws Crash Underage Drinking Parties Response

This newspaper article was helpful because I'm getting all different sides of the viewpoints. I definitely do not think that parents should be charged for something their child did. If the parent had no knowledge of it then how is it their fault at all. I would my child pay if they were the ones who hosted the party. It's just not fair. You would think that if you notice more and more parties are being caught then you probably shouldn't host one or go to one because you are most likely going to get caught. It's common sense. It would really stink to get caught with alcohol while you were underage, it would not be good. It was very hard to believe that in a three month period 300 parties were caught. That's just ridiculous. That's just in that one area. Imagine how many others around the nation there would be! Way too many, this has to stop. The story about the 19 year-old is just funny. He must be one stupid kid or maybe he just doesn't care at all.

Laws Crash Underage Drinking Parties--6

This is a story about a couple who left their underage daughter home and their was a party thrown.




  • A couple went on a realxing vacation leaving their daughter home alone.
  • She invited 3 friends over and within an hour 100 were there.

  • They got a call and the police and gotten a call about noise and they went to the house and found alcohol.

  • The family was charged 1,000 dollars.

  • The father said he would not pay, he didn't do it.

  • More and more teens are throwing parties when their parents leave and more and more of them are getting busted.

  • Adults are getting in trouble for things their teens are doing withouth their knowledge.
  • Underage drinking costs the nation 53 billion dollars a year. With car accidents and crime.
  • In 2004, in a three month period police busted 300 parties. 300!
  • A 19 year-old was caught once hosting a party while his parents were gone. Then a week before they were supposed to be home he held another one and got caught again! How dumb do you get?

Consider options on Underage Drinking Response

This website really shocked me. Why would anyone ever look at someones ID and then serve them alcohol even though they know that the person is underage? That makes no sense to me whatsoever. Either they are 21 or they don't get any alcohol. I also think that it's kind of a dumb law that was made that you had to ask for identification everytime you sold someone alcohol. Like the article said, why do you need to ask a senior citizen or someone who is obviously over the age of 21? It doesn't make much sense. I think that if you aren't really sure, then ask for and ID and if they don't have one, then no alcohol for them. I don't see the challenge in this. Maybe i'm missing the point but I don't know. I'm kind of against their idea of lowering the drinking age down to 18 to make it easier for them to deal with the issue. From all the other sites and articles I've read, it all screams no to me and that's what I'm going to stick with.

Consider options on underage drinking--5

  • When it's around the holiday season it's more likely for underage drinking to go on. People have parties and celebrate and there's almost always drinking involved.
  • The illegal consumption of alcohol in restaurants is a big deal lately.
  • In West Knoxville, police there did a test to see how many would get sold alcohol even if their ID's were checked and they were underage.
  • 14 out 0f 41 restaurants they went to checked their ID's and sold them alcohol anyway.
  • That's not a big number but that should never happen.
  • This is also happening at convienent stores too.
  • It's a law at convienant stores now that you have to check everyone's ID reagardless of their age.
  • This law was exemped in late 2007 because senior citizens were sometimes offended, i mean come on why would you ever ask to see their ID's.
  • A few ideas were made that the drinking age should just be lowered and that would not be a problem.

Underage Drinking in the U.S. and other countries response

I liked that website a lot. There has always been a controversy that other foreign countries lowered their drinking ages and that there has been a lot less drinking problems. This just proves that's not actually the case at all. I'm not sure, but the percentage may be off a bit or possibly a lot because of the amounts of people in the different countries. Even without a mistake it kind of gives an idea of what would happen if you did lower the drinking age. Of course the percentage would go up, but would we be more responsible? I don't think that it's easy to tell or not. That would probably be the only problem that I would have with lowering the age. It's just hard to tell what will actually happen and if it turns out bad, there's no going back and changing the age right away. The decision would be huge.

Underage Drinking in U.S. and Other Countries--4

I was told that I should compare the drinking stats to those in other countries and I found a great chart that gave a lot of information.

  • Many people say that since the drinking age is lower in other countries then the amount of drinking will decrease because the people will be more responsible.
  • This is proven to be a false fact.
  • This article showed that Turkey and the United States had the lowest percentage of underage drinkers.
  • The United Kingdom had a 75 percentage of drinkers in their country.
  • I guess the United States is fat, but the United Kingdom drinks a lot.